This video from Michael Martens (KB9VBR) has changed my mind.
In this video, Michael discusses the pros and cons of this simple, effective vertical antenna. Michael feels the J-Pole may be the "ultimate" vertical antenna for the 10 meter band.
If you can't see the video, please insert this title URL into your browser search box: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZv94BvNxrQ.
Here are some comments from Michael (KB9VBR):
Chapters
Introduction
Why I don't sell 10 meter antennas
What is a J-Pole antenna
10 meter J-Pole antenna dimensions
Building a 10 meter J-Pole Antenna
Deploying the antenna
Testing the J-Pole during the ARRL 10 meter contest
Contest results and my thoughts on the 10 Meter J-Pole
Transcript
KB9VBR Antennas